Natural Way Peanut Butter

No, Natural Way peanut butter does not need to be refrigerated after opening. You can refrigerate if you want to keep a thicker consistency, but it is not necessary.

Yes. Our ingredients are natural ingredients, so oil separation is normal. We recommend that you stir from the bottom when oil separation does occur. 

Natural Way peanut butter is good for one year from the date of manufacture. You can check the best by date on the bottom of the jar. Once opened, consume within 6 months for best taste and texture.

We are always working to bring new and exciting flavors of our natural peanut butter to our customers. If you have a new flavor suggestion, please let us know through the Contact form.


You can purchase our products from our website or in grocery and retail stores across the US.
To find a store near you, check out our Store Locator!

One option is to speak to the Grocery Manager where you shop. You can tell them you’d love to see Natural Way products on the shelf, and be sure to mention your favorite items. Or, you can direct them to our Contact page. From there, we’d be happy to help them.
Until then, you can order directly from our website. You can also use our Store Locator to see if there’s a place near you that sells our products.

Yes. Our products are carried by grocery stores, retail stores, and movie theatres in the US. If you would like to carry Natural Way products please visit our Contact form or send us an email at

Unfortunately, we do not offer returns or refunds because we offer food products. If you receive a shipment that has been  damaged please reach out to us at, and we will be happy to assist you.